INTERNET ACCESS ON THE WATER- A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW
There are two primary alternatives for boaters in the Washington and BC who want to access the internet while cruising: 3 G cellular service or WiFi. In this article we will explain the services in easy to understand terminology and then examine these alternatives based on 3 criteria: price, allowable data, contract term, speed, availability, quality of service, roaming and equipment.
SPEED:
The measure of speed in the article is kilobits per second (kbps). For a basis of comparison top dialup speed in the US is commonly 56 kbps. Common dsl in your home is 768kbps to 3000 kbps of more commonly known as Megabits per second(mbps). The best speed from cable in Washington is Comcast with speeds that commonly reaching 6mbps to a high of 30mbps for upgraded workplace solutions.
WHAT IS 3 G CELLULAR:
3G is the wide are cellular network that currently offers the highest speed. In this article we use the Verizon high speed wireless card as the benchmark as it is the most well know and very reliable. In Canada, Rogers or Telus should be similar.
WHAT IS WIFI:
WiFi is the common name for the radio broadcast in the 2.4 GHz band and offers 11 channels of broadcast. It is a line of sight technology and can offer service speeds up to 54 Mbits with distances up to 5 miles with external antennas. We will use BroadbandXpress as the benchmark in this article as it has 110 locations in Washington and BC markets
Now lets benchmark the 2 services:
PRICE:
Verizon: $79.99 per month($59.99 per month 12-24 month contract with approx extra $20.00 in taxes-varies per district)
BroadbandXpress: $24.91 per month based upon $299.99 prepaid annual service(short term plans of $10.95 available)
Annual Subscription Cost: Verizon $959.88/BroadbandXpress $299.99
ALLOWABLE DATA:
Roaming between countries is an issue that needs to be reviewed very carefully when using cell company data plans. Huge roaming costs can be incurred. In addition, Verizon has a specific data cap and no warning is given when you exceed the limit. The rule is download movies and other applications from home and do not run any peer to peer networks on any network. The direct line for Verizon Wireless global is 908-559-4899. Call them to verify all the details before your trip to ensure no surprises.
Verizon: 5GB limit per monthly billing cycle(5120 megabyte-MB): excess charge of $.25 MB in US
Typical file size: digital photo 6MB/Movie 4000MB-8000 MB
Cost to view a 4 GB movie if you exceed download limit USA: $1,000.00
BroadbandXpress: no caps-does not support movie downloads or file sharing
CONTRACT TERM:
Verizon:12-24 month(discounts on equipment for longer term)
BroadbandXpress: 24 hours, 72hours, 7 days, 30 days, 1 year
SPEED:
Verizon: download 600kbps-1400kpbs(1.4 mbps)
BroadbandXpress: download: 2200 kbps-10,000 kbps(10 mbps) shared- speed may be less and depends upon quality of equipment used.
AVAILABILITY:
Verizon: generally everywhere there is a good cell signal. Poor cell signal will deteriorate data performance. Point Roberts and Deer Harbor are 2 locations with extremely poor signal quality and no service. Large gaps in service in Canada.
BroadbandXpress: Available only in line of site of their 110 locations in Washington and BC. Go to www.bbxpress.net for more detailed information.
QUALITY OF SERVICE:
Verizon: Excellent for normal web usage. Large latency of 200-300 milliseconds makes internet applications such as gaming, skype, vonage too poor for most users.
BroadbandXpress: Excellent in coverage areas. Requires BroadbandXpress hardware for quality of service. Latency is acceptable generally at 20-50 milliseconds.
To adequately test the download, upload and latency of any broadband network go to www.speedtest.net and run a test.
ROAMING:
Verizon: Roaming into Canada an additional cost under national plan: $2.00 per MB
Cost of send a typical 6 MB high resolution digital photo: $12.00
Cost to view a 4GB movie if you roam into Canada: $8,000.00
BroadbandXpress: No roaming fee. All locations included.
EQUIPMENT:
Verizon: $99.99-$199.99 for usb or other device.
BroadbandXpress: $89.99 for standard usb and up to $899.99 for a complete onboard wireless network
OVERALL:
Each service has its positives and negatives. The overall minimum cost of the Verizon service is approx $1059 with their minimum hardware versus $389.98 for the BroadbandXpress service with minimum recommended hardware. The coverage area of the Verizon service is vastly superior in the United States but the speed is much slower. The most import difference is the huge cost of exceeding your allowable data plan under the Verizon service plus the excessive cost of data roaming. Our most important recommendation is do your homework and make sure you test the services and are familiar with the hardware 30-60 days before you will depend upon it.
If you want to avoid our Friend below, watch out for the roaming.
Currently rated 3.0 by 2 people
- Currently 3/5 Stars.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5